Monster Shark Tournament – Champion List
| Year | Venue | 1st Place | Species | Weight |
| 2019 | Fairhaven | Outta Line | Porbeagle / Thresher | 376 / 365 |
| 2018 | New Bedford | Legit Fish | Mako | 327 |
| 2017 | New Bedford | Black Rose | Thresher | 360 |
| 2016 | New Bedford | Nece$$ary Expen$e | Thresher | 412 |
| 2015 | Newport | Magellan | 2 Porbeagles | 432 / 354 |
| 2014 | Newport | Magellan | 2 Porbeagles | 430 / 378 |
| 2013 | Oak Bluffs | Magellan | 2 Porbeagles | 429 / 313 |
| 2012 | Oak Bluffs | Lady Diana | Porbeagle | 447 |
| 2011 | Oak Bluffs | Tuna Tangler Too | Thresher / Mako | 538 / 278 |
| 2010 | Oak Bluffs | Tuna Tangler Too | Thresher | 413 |
| 2009 | Oak Bluffs | Karen Jean II | Porbeagle | 361 |
| 2008 | Oak Bluffs | Waterbury | Thresher | 399 |
| 2007 | Oak Bluffs | Provider | 2 Threshers | 327 / 311 |
| 2006 | Oak Bluffs | Clan Mac Gregor | Thresher | 482 |
| 2005 | Oak Bluffs | Bobby’s Girl | 2 Porbeagles | 378 / 378 |
| 2004 | Oak Bluffs | Cookie Too | 2 Threshers | 548 / 262 |
| 2003 | Oak Bluffs | Billfish | Thresher | 506 |
| 2002 | Oak Bluffs | Magic Lady | Blue | 383 |
| 2001 | Oak Bluffs | Dazed and Confused | Mako | 1,221 |
| 2000 | Oak Bluffs | Shortfin | Blue | 311 |
| 1999 | Oak Bluffs | Javelin | Mako | 330 |
| 1998 | Oak Bluffs | St. Jude | 2 Blues | 330 / 327 |
| 1997 | Oak Bluffs | Raven | Blue | 337 |
| 1996 | Oak Bluffs | Reel Good | Blue | 356 |
| 1995 | Oak Bluffs | Fish Finder | Blue | 320 |
| 1994 | Oak Bluffs | Pauline | Blue | 360 |
| 1993 | Oak Bluffs | Bow Wow Wow | Mako / Blue | 784 / 381 |
| 1992 | Oak Bluffs | Reel Good | Blue | 360 |
| 1991 | Oak Bluffs | Fish N Boat | Blue | 337 |
| 1990 | Oak Bluffs | Bottom Line | Dusky | 424 |
| 1989 | Oak Bluffs | Tailwalker | Blue | 341 |
| 1988 | Oak Bluffs | Bounty Hunter | ||
| 1987 | Oak Bluffs | Renegade | Tiger | 452 |
North Atlantic Shark Tournament
| Year | Venue | 1st Place | Species | Weight |
| 2016 | Merged back with the Monster Shark Tournament | |||
| 2015 | New Bedford | Sole Mate | Porbeagle | 329 |
| 2014 | New Bedford | Beagle | Mako | 282 |
